This shorter piece is even more clear-cut about the issues, and the lead includes her conversation with Dr. A. Normal Guthkelch, the British neuropathologist who first proposed shaking as a mechanism of infant brain injury in 1971. Dr. Guthkelch now says he’s worried that shaking theory is used in the courtroom to target innocent caregivers, as reported last summer by NPR.
The Slate piece is especially welcome right now, when most of the press coverage seems to accept without question the classic model. In Missouri, for example, a state legislator has proposed a bill to lengthen sentences for people convicted of abuse through shaking, as reported in the Missourian.