Category Archives: Uncategorized

A Coerced Confession Backfires

Because of real investigative journalism by WBUR, Boston’s public radio station, a Massachusetts judge has reluctantly released a moving videotape of a heartless two-hour police interrogation of a teenage mother the day after her baby’s death.

In the video Nga Truang, a slight Vietnamese-American a few days shy of her 17th birthday, sits motionless and cries softly as two full-size Worcester, Massachusetts detectives badger her to come clean with them. The detectives tell her a number of lies, including the false information that an autopsy proved 13-month-old Khyle had been suffocated. In fact, the autopsy was inconclusive: her son had been sick with strep throat and tracheobronchitis when he died, and he had a history of breathing problems; his temperature an hour after death was still at 101°F.

Still, after the detectives make promises of leniency and help, she tells them, yes, she smothered her baby. Of course she received no help: She spent the next three years in jail while attorneys argued about the admissibility of the confession, which was ultimately rejected by a judge—the primary reason seems to be that she should have received more careful Miranda warnings at her young age.

This afternoon NPR ran a feature story about the case:   The story NPR ran today

WBUR also posted its own treatment, which starts at this link.

WBUR also posted excerpts of the videos and additional commentary by the reporter, at excerpts  and commentary.

2 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

Pardon Possible in Smith Case

It’s too early to celebrate, but the Sacramento Bee reports that Governor Jerry Brown is expected to pardon Shirley Ree Smith, the grandmother whose conviction in a shaking case was recently reaffirmed by the Supreme Court:

http://www.sacbee.com/2011/12/29/4150363/calif-gov-brown-weighs-clemency.html

Leave a comment

Filed under abusive head trauma, AHT, SBS, shaken baby syndrome, Uncategorized

We’re Not Alone

Bad news with the thinnest possible silver lining out of Florida.

On Sunday morning of this week paramedics were called to the home of an unresponsive 5-month-old in the suburbs of Orlando. The family said the little girl had vomited and quit breathing, but doctors have diagnosed her as a shaken baby.

The television news team interviewed a neighbor of the family and a passer-by at the hospital, conversations driven by the assumption that the diagnosis is correct. The on-line comments started with the usual berating of anyone who would do this to a child, but then two people with names I’ve not seen before posted cautionary notes, one citing general criticism of the theory and one suggesting vaccine reaction.

You can see the whole thing at:

http://www.clickorlando.com/news/29026667/detail.html

You have to click “Enable Comments” to see the comments.

For a scary experience, change the comment list order from “Newest First” to “Best Rating,” where the most popular post opens, “This is just another reason we need a licensing system to control
breeding…”

I don’t know what happened in this case, of course. The news reports mentioned only intracranial symptoms, and said the child is not recovering. My heart goes out to the family.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized