An Important Story, Well Told

EdgesOfTruthI first heard about Mary Weaver in 1998, in a prescient ABA Journal article by Mark Hansen, who called her “a poster child” for caretakers falsely accused of shaking babies. Weaver’s conviction was overturned in 1997, Hansen wrote, after new witnesses came forward to report that the 11-month-old who quit breathing in her care had been knocked unconscious in a fall earlier in the day.

Weaver’s attorney Steven Brennecke told me then that he wanted to write a book about the case—and now he has, in collaboration with Christian writer Deb Brammer. Edges of Truth: The Mary Weaver Story is being released on Friday, November 22, 2013.

Edges follows both Weaver and Brennecke closely, from the terrifying meltdown through the unthinkable accusations, three full-on trials, a glacier of appeals, and two years in prison for Weaver. I admit I was impatient at first with the pacing, but when I realized the ultimately reflective nature of the narration, I gave myself over and was glad I did.

A summary of Mary Weaver's case, from the National Registry of Exonerations.

A summary of Mary Weaver’s case, from the National Registry of Exonerations

Like It Happened to Audrey and When Truth No Longer MattersEdges illustrates how an early diagnosis of infant shaking can mislead investigators into targeting an innocent caretaker. But Edges also follows the spiritual journeys of the protagonists. While reading her Bible and talking with the prison chaplain and his wife, Weaver realizes she is living her ministry, but not by preaching: God has brought her to a place where others are comforted by the peace she carries with her, a peace made possible by her faith. The experience for her husband and young children is more about survival, while Brennecke faces his own spiritual crisis, as his best efforts as an attorney leave a woman he knows to be innocent in prison, and two children without their loving mother.

Myself, I was struck by the universal nature of the messages:  There are things you have no control over; your only option is to control how you respond, for example.

Three personal tales of women ultimately exonerated of infant shaking have been published in the past year—the stories of Mary Weaver, Audrey Edmunds, and Heather Toomey—all of them moving and sobering. I do look forward to wrapping up my own book and adding it to the shelves, although my protagonist was never exonerated, alas.

What I really want is for the people who make these diagnoses and pursue these prosecutions to  think more carefully when presented with cases of infant head injury. I am so weary of innocent parents and babysitters flattened by the opinions of people who have never even heard what the caretaker had to say.

I posted a blog entry about Weaver’s case this past spring, and the National Registry of Exonerations has posted this summary of her story.

If you are not familiar with the debate surrounding shaken baby syndrome and infant head trauma, please see the home page of this site.


Filed under abusive head trauma, AHT, Falsely accused, SBS, shaken baby syndrome

12 responses to “An Important Story, Well Told

  1. Pingback: The Forensic Unreliability of the Shaken Baby Syndrome: The Book | On Shaken Baby

  2. Pingback: Old Cases, New Cases, Sad Cases, True Cases | On SBS

  3. Pingback: Appeals All Over the Map, as Usual | On SBS

  4. Lynn D

    Just finished the Mary Weaver book, Edges of Truth, and I find myself so grateful for the outcome, as I personally know Mary. I am also shocked that there wasn’t any further inquiry into who was responsible for her death.

  5. Another Susan

    I ordered the book. I always learn from your blog. Thank you for writing it and giving people hope. All may not be lost, even after conviction. Though it seems like you’re all alone after you’ve been accused, you are not alone. There are still people who care about justice, like Sue L.

  6. The note from Nikki is interesting. We live in New Zealand and realize that it also faces these issues. Deb Brammer, Author of Edges of Truth

  7. Pat

    Great job Sue on getting this out to the
    public. Good luck on getting your book
    out, also.
    Pat C.

  8. Nikki

    Having been through the most harrowing experience of my life…being accused of shaking my baby, children taken away, etc etc etc my heart goes out to anyone who’s been in the similar position. Thankfully in the end I didn’t have to go to court and my children are in my care but I’m so appalled by the continuing injustices I’ve vowed to do my best to change the way these cases are dealt with in New Zealand so other people don’t have to go through the same. One day these so called medical professionals will have to pull their heads out of their, um, hats.

    • Sehrish

      Hi right now I am in same baby is taken away from me as he had brain bleed. My case in court please pray for me. I am a single mother that’s more hard because they are accusing me for shaking him.its been 6 monts now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.